first published in Juxtapoz Magazine, December 20, 2019


Two Hands, One Brush: Tamsin Smith & Emilio Villalba Collaborate @ Adobe Books Gallery



Tamsin Smith + Emilio Villalba

Adobe Books Gallery

3130 24th Street, San Francisco

Exhibition: Nov 22-Dec 9, 2019


Painting collaborations are typically plagued by the inability of artists to let go of their own respective styles. Invariably, the painters end up grafting their independent gestures and motifs onto a single canvas. While we can call the resulting artwork a joint effort, it doesn’t usually present the viewer with new revelations. As exciting as the prospect of a successful collision may be, it is rarely achieved.

The joint work of Robert Rauschenberg and Jasper Johns in the 1950s comes to mind in this regard. They each generally took one portion of the canvas as their own territory. This compartmentalization usually meant that one artist was dominant and the other subservient, in some cases appearing in only 1/5th of the canvas.  

Alphabet 5

Tamsin Smith & Emilio Villalba, Alphabet V, oil on panel, 30.5” x 30.5” (2019).

With the Andy Warhol and Jean-Michel Basquiat’s collaborations of the 1980s, each took turns placing their distinctive iconography onto a single canvas until they declared the piece completed.  At the end of the process, once again, the viewer could easily parse which artist rendered which part.

Overcoming the inherent limitations of collaboration is what makes the work of Tamsin Smith and Emilio Villalba so exciting. In their recent show at Adobe Books Gallery, The Painter’s Alphabet, these two painters managed to let go of their own personal styles, in pursuit of more than the sum of their parts. Consistent with the historical antecedents their efforts didn’t start this way. Smith and Villalba had made a couple of joint works, which they exhibited at Modern Eden Gallery earlier in the year. In these, the artists painted the objects and scenes they were accustomed to painting, in unison or close proximity to the other’s, upon a single canvas.

Alphabet 12

Tamsin Smith & Emilio Villalba, Alphabet XII, oil on canvas, 24.5” x 36.5” (2019).

With time, this simple way of sharing space wasn’t satisfying to them.  They wanted to find a shared language and were willing to take the risks necessary to get there. Namely, that they exposed themselves to alienating viewers who had come to appreciate their individual work by presenting something wholly new. The upside was that they would be forging a novel and unified body of work.

In the case of Smith, a poet who has expanded creatively into painting, her work favors idiosyncratic figurative interior spaces, colorful landscapes with thick brush strokes, and a loose abstraction less harnessed by geometric or hard-edge lines as with curvature. The more established Villalba has won a robust following by utilizing portraiture, particularly with distorted and blurred compositions. A deft painter of details, eyes, and objects, he doesn’t typically paint in full abstraction. Yet, in this series of 15 pieces, the duo abandon their singular habits and create a dynamic unifying vernacular.


Tamsin Smith & Emilio Villalba, at Adobe Books Gallery, November 23, 2019. Photo by Matt Gonzalez.

So how did they do it? Smith and Villalba implemented a painting regiment, which they call the “painter’s alphabet” It involves each taking turns working through a sequence of directional mark making. The marks — known to visual artists as a drawing alphabet — begin with vertical and horizontal lines, then diagonal lines applied in alternative directions, followed by “S” and “C” curves.

Each artist is present as the other paints. They always work together and they don’t depart from the set rules. Although the determination of when a piece is completed is open. They keep cycling through the rotation of marks as they seek a place that satisfies a newfound collective aesthetic. In doing so, both artists own the finished product, so much so that neither can truly say “that’s my line” for a particular mark. As Villalba noted in a recent interview: “It’s impossible to get the painting you want out of it”. This comment underscores the extent to which they had to let go of expectations to really arrive at a fresh and unpredictable place.  As Smith observed “by removing the ability to lean on personal patterns or go-to skills of portraiture and figuration, [we] create[d] work that neither would or could have composed alone.”

Alphabet 6

Tamsin Smith & Emilio Villalba, Alphabet VI, oil on canvas, 36.5”x 48.5” (2019). Collection of Bryan Vereschagin & Lena Dokuchaeva.

On at least one occasion, the artists employed a dice throw to dictate the number of times of a particular type of mark would be made. This inclusion of chance is reminiscent of Surrealism, which historically speaking, greatly influenced the New York Abstract Expressionist, whose shadow Smith and Villalba work under. The dice was also consulted at times to dictate the rotation and orientation of the canvas.

The resulting pieces are surprisingly unified. Speaking of the paintings, Smith likens the rules they used to reading a book of haiku: “there’s a similar format, even if each [painting] is evoking a different feeling about a different season. There’s a nice wholeness to them, even though each is distinct.”

Alphabet 1

Tamsin Smith & Emilio Villalba, Alphabet I, oil on panel, 24.5”x 24.5” (2019).

The Basquiat-Warhol collaborations are noteworthy for their failure. What started as a collaboration between three artists (Francesco Clemente was initially included); then was reduced to the remaining two painters taking turns placing their own marks and imagery over the works of the other. Warhol typically started a painting by using a silk-screened image, a logo or some commercially known imagery down first, with Basquiat then writing text or directly painting over the imagery.

Basquiat and Warhol didn’t work at the same time on a piece, rather the surface was shuttled back and forth between their studios. By the end of the effort, an animosity grew between them. The resulting work was not well received when exhibited in 1985.

Alphabet 8

Tamsin Smith & Emilio Villalba, Alphabet VIII, oil on panel, 24.5” x 30.5” (2019).

In contrast to this, the Smith-Villalba collaborations occur with different artists taking the first turn and a refusal to rely on established patterns or iconography. Always present when the other painted on the canvases, any reaction either painter had to brush strokes the other placed would be sorted out in the moment. Although the rules set parameters, it didn’t wholly make the process deterministic.  The number of gestures, placement of those marks, and the color choices, kept the process hinged to a freedom of choice the painters needed to fully express themselves, and yet the painters achieved a pattern of being something other than themselves. Their friendship has only grown as they’ve worked within the confines of the rules they strictly followed and which they learned to push up against.

In the end, the Smith-Villalba collaborations refute the popular myth of a solitary painter alone in a studio facing off against a canvas.  Their approach, which could be called a forced unlearning, offered an entryway into a language that actually takes two to be communicated. There is a dynamic energy and call-and-response harmonizing that is palpable. Confident, even exuberant abstraction and mark-marking results. Keep an eye out for future exhibitions by these artists. The pieces are numbered suggesting this is only the first chapter in what will be an ongoing series.

–Matt Gonzalez


NOTE: quotations by Villalba and Smith are from Waiting to Dry Podcast: Episode #84, Emilio Villalba & Tamsin Smith, “No small talk on the canvas,” September 17, 2019; and from the promotional announcement for the exhibition (written by Smith).


More painting collaborations by Tamsin Smith & Emilio Villalba:

Alphabet 9

Tamsin Smith & Emilio Villalba, Alphabet IX, oil on found wood panel, 27”x 27” (2019). Collection of Esteban Ortega Brown.

Alphabet 2

Tamsin Smith & Emilio Villalba, Alphabet II, oil on canvas, 24.5”x 24.5” (2019).

Alphabet 3

Tamsin Smith & Emilio Villalba, Alphabet III, oil on panel, 24.5” x 30.5” (2019).

Alphabet 4

Tamsin Smith & Emilio Villalba, Alphabet IV, oil on canvas, 30.5” x 30.5” (2019).

Alphabet 10

Tamsin Smith & Emilio Villalba, Alphabet X, oil on canvas, 36.5” x 36.5” (2019).

Alphabet 15

Tamsin Smith & Emilio Villalba, Alphabet XV triptych, oil on paper, 44” x 35” (2019).

Alphabet 11

Tamsin Smith & Emilio Villalba, Alphabet XI, oil on panel, 18.5” x 18.5” (2019).


One comment

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: